Season 1

Tapeworms and an all-inclusive starvation resort for the rich? Michelle tells us about deadly diets along with the story of Linda Hazzard and her murders at Starvation Heights.  Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our other shows from Scary.fm...

The Dyatlov Pass Incident riddle: In February 1959, nine hikers died in the Ural mountains and were found under bizarre conditions with crushed skulls, missing eyes, and some were half-dressed. No murder weapon and no signs of foul play were found. What killed them?  Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire...

Michelle thinks that what we're missing in the U.S. is a good set of Christmas witches. Krampus was so 2011. Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our other shows from Scary.fm for more scares!

The Jim Twins were two brothers that were separated at birth but lived bizarrely similar lives. If they could communicate telepathically, then maybe we can too? Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our other shows from Scary.fm for more scares!

The Winchester Mystery House in San Jose, California was rumored to be built in order to please (or confuse) spirits of those killed by the family's gun company by Sarah Winchester. But something in that story doesn't make sense... and Michelle tells us all about it. Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire...

This episode is about cannibalism, and there's mention of recipes, fetishes, and real cases. Things got rough for our stomachs during the recording, so if you're sensitive to that type of thing, like we are, listen to Edwin's favorite episode Fat Lady Barber of Pike Place instead. Happy Thanksgiving...

Since August 20, 2007, at least 20 detached human feet have been found on the coasts of the Salish Sea in British Columbia, Canada, and Washington, US. A tale that reminds Michelle of home sweet home.  Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our o...

In the 90s, the chupacabras took over the news. It was portrayed as a creature that lurked in the desert and killed animals by drinking their blood. Edwin never got his chupacabra t-shirt. Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our other shows fr...

Edwin tells us about Día de los muertos (Day of the Dead), a Mexican tradition that celebrates the lives of those who have passed by setting up food, flowers, and colorful festivities to welcome the dead as they come hang out for the night.  Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being...

After finding a list of haunted numbers on the internet that are said to curse those who dial them, Michelle got an idea: why don't we call them and see what happens? Scary Mystery Surprise (Campfire Story) is no longer being updated, but be sure to check out our other shows from Scary.fm for more s...